Inserting a profit motive into the states power to imprison is fraught with ethical and legal issues
Short answer – more than 80 words
1. Inserting a profit motive into the state’s power to imprison is fraught with ethical and legal issues. Despite critics, the industry of private prisons is big business, bringing in over $3 billion per year (as cited in Pollock, 2019). There have been instances of rigged bidding (where politicians and decision makers are rewarded for sending contracts to certain firms), contract performance problems (when private companies don’t provide the services they promised), and issues with poorly trained or overworked staff (leading to violence and escapes). Some believe that punishment and profit are never compatible and that linking the two has led to a variety of historical abuses (such as the contract labor system in the south) and current scandals. Have “corrections” become political? Is there a good answer/solution?
2. general response – “I agree” or more than 80 words
In 2006 and 2008, the Federal Bureau of Prisons (BOP or “Bureau”) secretly created the Communications Management Units (CMUs), prison units designed to isolate and segregate certain prisoners in the federal prison system from the rest of the BOP population. Currently, there are two CMUs, one located in Terre Haute, Indiana and the other in Marion, Illinois. The CMUs house between 60 and 70 prisoners in total, and approximately 60 percent of the CMU population is Muslim, even though Muslims represent only 6 percent of the general federal prison population. Constitutional safeguards provided by US Constitution in the 4th, 5th and 6th amendments in regards to the criminal justice system are implemented to protect people against indiscriminate application of criminal laws and wanton treatment of persons suspected of violating the law. The amendments which are specifically designed to enforce constitutional rights of suspected criminal proceedings and trials have been altered by these safeguards provided for by the amendments whereby the courts are required to conducts the proceedings or trials in a manner that is in conformity with the safeguards. or the first time, an NPR investigation has identified 86 of the more than 100 men who have lived in the special units that some people are calling “Guantanamo North.” The Communications Management Units in Terre Haute, Ind., and Marion, Ill., are mostly filled with Muslims. About two-thirds of the inmates identified by NPR are U.S. citizens. Civil rights groups have filed lawsuits that accuse the U.S. facilities of some of the same due process complaints raised by people at the island prison.
Answer preview for Inserting a profit motive into the states power to imprison is fraught with ethical and legal issues
Access the full answer containing 230 words by clicking the below purchase button.